Other states already do this

Proven models, not a new idea

Colorado would not be inventing anything new. Multiple states already distinguish bona fide fraternal and nonprofit organizations from ordinary commercial businesses and permit limited electronic gaming under licensing, age restrictions, testing, monitoring, auditing, taxation, location restrictions, and charitable-purpose requirements.

NM

New Mexico

Since 1997 · Gaming Control Board

  • Licensed nonprofit veterans and fraternal operators (501(c)(8) and (c)(10)) at their own premises
  • Up to 15 machines; $10,000 maximum prize
  • Play by active and auxiliary members only
  • 10% gaming tax for nonprofit operators; 20% or more of the balance to charity or education

The longest-running example of gaming machines inside qualifying fraternal nonprofits.

OH

Ohio

Since 2021 · Attorney General

  • Veterans and fraternal organizations at their principal place of business; members and guests
  • Up to 10 electronic instant bingo devices
  • Required charitable shares: 25% or more of the first $250,000 in net profit, 50% or more above that

An eligibility lock limited to veterans and fraternal organizations at their principal place of business. In Colorado, the equivalent is existing bingo-raffle licensees that meet the 5-year rule.

WV

West Virginia

Since 2001 · Lottery Commission

  • Retailers plus 501(c)(8), (c)(10), and (c)(19) organizations, in adult-only restricted areas
  • Up to 10 limited video lottery terminals
  • State-run revenue distribution

About 25 years of experience, with express recognition of qualifying fraternal and veterans organizations in machine-gaming law.

IL

Illinois

Since 2009 · Illinois Gaming Board

  • Licensed locations, including fraternal and veterans establishments (501(c)(8), (c)(10), (c)(19))
  • Up to 6 video gaming terminals, centrally monitored; 21+
  • Towns may opt out
  • State tax on net terminal income; remainder shared by operator and location

A mature regulatory system that has maintained a separate, protected category for fraternal organizations for well over a decade.

NE

Nebraska

Since 2019 · Department of Revenue

  • Licensed locations under LB685 (2024), with special treatment for fraternal benefit societies and veterans organizations
  • Generally 5 devices; 21+ only
  • Independent laboratory testing and a state central monitoring system
  • Device tax administered by the state

Another neighboring state with testing, central monitoring, and special treatment written into law for fraternal and veterans organizations.

WY

Wyoming

Since 2020 · Wyoming Gaming Commission

  • Licensed establishments, including qualifying fraternal club locations
  • Skill must be the primary factor; 21+ only
  • Up to 4 machines; $3 maximum play; $3,000 maximum payout
  • 20% of net proceeds: 45% local government, 45% schools, 10% regulator

A neighboring state shows that cash-paying electronic skill games can be licensed, tested, taxed, age-restricted, and tightly capped.

About $1 million given to charity in fiscal year 2024 by 46 licensed nonprofit operators in New Mexico.
901 sites · 6,750 machines electronic instant bingo in Ohio as of March 2024.

What Colorado can take from these models

  • New Mexico: the longest-running example of gaming machines inside qualifying fraternal nonprofits, with members-only play and a low tax rate for nonprofits paired with a required minimum charitable share.
  • Wyoming and Nebraska: clear statutory frameworks from two neighbors, with 21+ play, independent testing and central monitoring, and in Nebraska, special treatment written into law for fraternal and veterans organizations.
  • Illinois: express inclusion of fraternal and veterans establishments in a mature regulatory system, with a local opt-out.
  • Ohio: an eligibility lock limited to veterans and fraternal organizations at their principal place of business.
  • West Virginia: about 25 years of experience, with express recognition of 501(c)(8), (c)(10), and (c)(19) organizations.

These states use different legal structures, and Colorado need not copy any of them word for word. Together they show that limited electronic gaming inside bona fide fraternal and veterans organizations is proven, workable public policy.